Connect with us

LIFESTYLE

NHS Birth Centres Shut as Midwife Numbers Hit a Record

Twelve NHS birth centres have shut since 2019, six under Labour, even as ministers cite 25,457 midwives and caesareans reach 45% of births.

Published

on

England has closed 12 midwife-led birth centres since 2019, six of them after Labour took office in July 2024. The NHS website still tells women they can choose home, a birth centre or hospital. Ministers say midwife numbers are at a record.

Those two facts sit in the same briefing pack. Trusts say they cannot staff the rooms. The payroll says the opposite. The work the extra midwives are doing is, increasingly, surgical.

The Website Still Offers Home, a Birth Centre or Hospital

The live NHS page on place of birth still sets out three options: home, a midwifery unit or hospital. It says a low-risk labour at home or in a midwife-run unit is less likely to end in forceps or ventouse than a hospital birth. It also says you can change your mind at any point in pregnancy.

Birthrights, the childbirth rights charity, is blunter. You have a right to choose where you give birth, it tells women, and no one can make you leave home if you want to stay there. NHS trusts are expected to run a home birth service. A pause is supposed to be a last step after every other option has been tried.

Hazel Williams, chief executive of Birthrights, said the closures and home-birth freezes of the past few years have gone far beyond a local rota problem.

These are not luxury options or nice-to-haves. This is about women and birthing people’s right to choose what happens to their bodies and their birth.

Hazel Williams, chief executive, Birthrights

Hannah Leonard, chief policy officer and deputy chief midwife at the Royal College of Midwives, said the same right is being eroded in practice. For some women, she said, a birth centre or a home birth improves outcomes and the experience for mother and baby. The college has also warned that if the NHS cannot offer midwife-led care, some women will pay privately, and some will labour at home with no health professional in the room.

The NHS page now even explains how to notify a birth after an unassisted labour, sometimes called freebirth, within 36 hours. That guidance exists because the law requires every birth in England to be recorded. It is also a quiet admission that some labours now happen outside the service.

Why Trusts Shut Centres While Headcount Rises

Asked about the closures, the Department of Health and Social Care did not answer the list of units. A spokesperson said every woman and baby deserves safe, compassionate maternity and neonatal care, and that strengthening the workforce is central to that goal. The department said there is now a record number of midwives in the NHS, with over 600 added in the past year.

Karin Smyth, the minister of state, put a harder number on the same claim in a written answer on 19 October 2026. The number of midwives working in the NHS has risen by around 1,900 since July 2024, she said, to 25,457 in July 2026. The government is also putting £10.6 million into 1,000 temporary roles to help newly qualified midwives join.

THE MIDWIFE PAYROLL

  • The headcount: 25,457 midwives in the NHS in July 2026, about 1,900 more than in July 2024, Karin Smyth told Parliament.
  • The past year: Ministers say over 600 midwives were added in the latest 12 months.
  • The leavers: The annual rate of midwives leaving active NHS service was 9.6% in the year to March 2026, down from 11.4% in the year to March 2023.
  • The graduate gap: In the East of England this spring, students were told there could be about 55 midwifery vacancies for around 300 people due to qualify.

That last figure is the part the closure letters do not mention. Trusts keep saying they cannot staff a birth centre safely. New midwives have been protesting because they cannot find a first post. Temporary money is being used to park graduates in 12-month jobs while the same trusts darken midwife-led rooms.

The shortage, in other words, is not a blank payroll. It is a roster that has been pulled onto consultant labour wards, triage, and theatres, and then declared too thin to keep a homely unit open overnight.

Midwife-Led Births Fell From 11.8% to 5.4%

The rooms were emptying before many of the doors were locked. A UK Midwifery Study System analysis of six national studies, covering 2016 to 2024, found that the share of UK births in alongside midwifery units, the midwife-led rooms attached to hospitals, fell from 11.8% in 2016 to 5.4% in 2023.

The chance of giving birth in one of those units was 56% lower in the latest study than in 2016. The authors said the drop was not explained by the number of units. There were still around 100 alongside units taking part, down from about 120, but use collapsed faster than the estate. In the later studies, about 7% of alongside units and about 20% of freestanding units reported they were closed to admissions for a whole month.

That collapse landed on top of a policy that had promised the opposite. The 2016 Better Births maternity review, chaired by Baroness Julia Cumberlege, said women should be able to choose home, a midwifery unit or an obstetric unit after a full discussion of benefits and risks. Continuity of carer, a small team of midwives who stay with a woman through pregnancy and birth, was the other pillar. Ten years later the choice architecture is still on the NHS website. The activity has moved.

The paper’s warning was about skill as much as buildings. If midwives rarely catch babies outside a consultant unit, the midwife-led option becomes harder to staff, then easier to close, then harder to reopen. That is the loop now visible in Yorkshire, Greater Manchester and East Sussex.

A Labour Ward Built for Surgery

The caseload that remains does not look like a birth-centre caseload. NHS Digital’s maternity statistics for 2024-25 show 542,235 deliveries in English NHS hospitals, down 0.5% on 2023-24. In that year, 45% of deliveries were caesarean. For women aged 30 and over, caesarean was the most common method. For women under 30, spontaneous birth still led.

HOW ENGLISH BIRTHS NOW LOOK

Measure Figure Period
Deliveries in English NHS hospitals 542,235 2024-25
Change on the previous year down 0.5% vs 2023-24
Share of deliveries by caesarean 45% 2024-25
UK share of births in alongside midwifery units 11.8% 2016
UK share of births in alongside midwifery units 5.4% 2023

A caesarean needs a theatre, an obstetrician, an anaesthetist and a neonatal team on hand. A freestanding birth centre, by design, has none of those in the building. Once 45% of hospital births are surgical, the safe default in a trust board paper is the consultant unit. The midwife-led room then looks like a second roster the labour ward can no longer spare.

Gill Walton, chief executive of the Royal College of Midwives, said changing patterns in childbirth, including rising caesarean and induction rates, mean the needs of women are evolving fast and services have to keep up. Dr Alison Wright, president of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, said independent investigations have already named growing demand and workforce shortages as drivers of poor care and preventable harm. She called for staffing, training, facilities and sustained investment so services can adapt.

That clinical argument is real. It is also the argument now used to switch the lights off in towns that never had a theatre of their own. Some clinicians go further and treat freestanding units as a drain on the consultant ward, a duplicate shift of midwives at a moment when nearly half of births need a surgeon. The safety record of midwife-led care for low-risk women is not the same as the staffing model required for a 45% caesarean service. Boards are choosing the second of those facts.

Huddersfield Has Been Closed for Six Years

The six permanent closures since July 2024 are in Rossendale in east Lancashire, Edgware in north London, Melton Mowbray in Leicestershire, Stafford and Lichfield in Staffordshire, and Pontefract in West Yorkshire. Four other centres remain “temporary”, some for so long that campaigners no longer believe the word. Two more shut because the hospitals around them are falling apart and will stay dark until new buildings go up.

THE CLOSURE CALENDAR

  1. February 2016: Better Births tells the NHS to offer home, a midwifery unit or hospital as a genuine choice.
  2. November 2020: Huddersfield birth centre closes as a Covid step. Six years later it is still shut.
  3. January 2022: Ingleside birth centre in Salford, opened in 2018, is suspended as a temporary measure.
  4. July 2024: Labour takes office. Six centres are later closed for good on its watch.
  5. October 2025: Midwife-led births stop at Crowborough in East Sussex after repeated short-notice shutdowns.
  6. Early November 2026: Gloucestershire says Cheltenham will reopen in February and home births will resume in January.

Calderdale and Huddersfield NHS Trust, which ran the Huddersfield centre, said no decision has been made to reopen and it cannot give a timeframe. Future decisions, it said, will rest on clinical safety, workforce sustainability and the needs of local women and families. Ingleside has now been “temporary” for almost five years. Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust, which runs Crowborough, said it has finished a review of what reopening would take, then declined to say what that would involve.

Nusrat Ghani, MP for Sussex Weald, said the trust has broken numerous promises and that local mothers now travel for up to 90 minutes in labour. She suggested the “temporary” label may be a way to avoid the public consultation a permanent closure would require. Home birth services in England and Wales have also been suspended for as long as 14 months at a stretch.

Tope Medupin, acting chief executive of the National Childbirth Trust, said the loss of a local service often means longer journeys, higher costs, greater uncertainty and fewer options at one of the most important times in a woman’s life. Longstanding workforce shortages, crumbling estates and wider pressure on maternity services, she said, remain unresolved. That, she said, cannot simply become the new normal.

Up to 20 Hospital Units Sit on the Same Logic

Birth centres are the small rooms. The next argument is about the hospitals. Matthew Hopkins, director for acute care at the NHS Alliance, which speaks for health managers, said in October 2026 that the way maternity care is organised is not fit for purpose. He said as many as 20 of England’s 155 consultant-led maternity units may have to close or change role so women and babies can be kept safe.

We are calling for a thorough appraisal of maternity services and where they need to be located because the current configuration is not fit for purpose.

Matthew Hopkins, director for acute care, NHS Alliance

Hopkins said smaller units that deliver around 1,500 to 2,000 babies a year, many of them rural or coastal, cannot keep a 24-hour obstetric, anaesthetic and neonatal rota standing while caesarean rates climb and buildings decay. Centralising those births into larger hospitals was, he said, inevitable and the right thing, and would be politically unpopular.

WHAT THE CONSOLIDATION CASE RESTS ON

  • Volume: Units in the 1,500 to 2,000 births a year band are the ones managers now call unsustainable.
  • Staff at night: Smaller sites struggle to keep midwives, obstetricians and anaesthetists on a safe 24-hour rota.
  • Theatres: A 45% caesarean service needs operating rooms and recovery beds that many older units do not have.
  • The next map: Norfolk bosses have already sketched options that would leave the Norfolk and Norwich as the county’s only consultant-led maternity unit.

The Norfolk sketch would close or downgrade maternity at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in King’s Lynn and the James Paget Hospital in Gorleston. Both sites have been delivering around 1,800 babies a year and also take women from north Suffolk, Lowestoft, Wisbech and north-east Cambridgeshire. The Royal College of Midwives said women in rural and isolated communities would face unacceptable distances in labour, and that neonatal units and children’s wards tend to close with the maternity unit because the services are tied together.

North Devon’s consultant-led unit in Barnstaple, including its home birth service, has already been closed for months for lack of staff. That is the Hopkins logic running in real time, before any national plan is published. If 20 hospital units follow the 12 birth centres, the three-way choice on the NHS website will describe a country that no longer exists outside a handful of cities.

Cooper’s Plan Arrives After the Doors Close

Yvette Cooper, the health secretary, chairs a national maternity and neonatal taskforce and is due to publish an action plan before Christmas. That plan is meant to answer Baroness Valerie Amos’s independent investigation, released on 30 June 2026, which found that the maternity and neonatal system in England is no longer fit to deliver high-quality, compassionate care consistently, and set out eight recommendations, including a statutory Maternity and Neonatal Commissioner.

The commissioner has been promised and, as of early November, has not been appointed. NHS England has published a 10-point list of urgent actions, including rolling Martha’s Rule into maternity and neonatal wards. Smyth’s £10.6 million for newly qualified midwives sits in the same pack. None of those steps reopens Rossendale, Edgware, Melton Mowbray, Stafford, Lichfield or Pontefract. None of them puts a midwife back into Huddersfield.

The first-baby home birth figures on the NHS’s own page are still the ones Better Births was written around. Serious problems for the baby, including death or harm that might affect quality of life, run at 5 in 1,000 for a hospital birth and 9 in 1,000 for a planned home birth. For women who have already had a baby, a planned home birth is described as as safe as hospital or a midwife-led unit. Those numbers only help a woman who still has a service to call.

Gloucestershire is the exception that proves how rare a reversal is. Cheltenham’s birth centre, shut since 2022, is due to reopen in February, and home births suspended since 2025 are due to resume in January. Crowborough, 90 minutes from the next labour ward for some mothers, has no date. The record midwife total and the dark birth rooms will both still be true when Cooper’s plan is printed.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of NHS maternity services in England. It is for information only and is not medical advice, and it is not a substitute for a discussion with your own midwife, obstetrician or GP about where you should give birth. Decisions about place of birth, including home birth, a midwifery unit or a consultant-led hospital, depend on your pregnancy, your health and the services actually running in your area, and you should take advice from a qualified maternity professional before acting on anything described here. Figures, unit statuses and reopening dates reflect the official statistics, parliamentary answers, trust statements and campaign briefings used in this piece and can change as trusts review staffing and as the national action plan is published.

Harry is the editor and lead writer of KERALANEWS 24X7, which he owns and runs as an independent publication. After ten years in journalism as a reporter and then an editor, he treats a story as something that keeps its history rather than a page that is silently replaced. When a report is updated, the new material is added with the time it arrived, and earlier text that turned out to be wrong is corrected in the open under the site's public corrections policy rather than deleted. Readers in any time zone can see how a story developed. Publishing around the clock never shortens the checking: the primary filing, statement, transcript or dataset is located first, and every number is confirmed against it before it appears. The site covers news, business and technology, science and sports, and entertainment, lifestyle and travel, with auto and gaming reported to the same standard, all for an international readership. Reader mail goes to Harry rather than to a form, at support@keralanews247.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending