NEWS
Ninth Circuit Locks NFL Liability, Sends Sunday Ticket Damages Back
The Ninth Circuit restored NFL Sunday Ticket antitrust liability on October 30, 2026, and ordered a new trial on the $4.7 billion award.
The Ninth Circuit on October 30, 2026, ordered a new trial on Sunday Ticket damages and restored the NFL’s antitrust liability verdict. The $4.7 billion figure from 2024 does not come back with it.
A three-judge panel kept the jury’s finding that the league and its 32 clubs broke federal law by pooling out-of-market games. It also kept the trial judge’s call that the money math was guesswork. That split is the ruling, and it is the piece the league is now taking to a larger court.
A Liability Verdict the Ninth Circuit Would Not Touch
Judge Anthony D. Johnstone wrote for a unanimous panel with Judge Holly A. Thomas and District Judge Joan H. Lefkow. They reversed U.S. District Judge Philip S. Gutierrez’s judgment as a matter of law for the NFL, which had erased the June 27, 2024, verdict after he threw out the subscribers’ experts. They affirmed his backup order for a new trial on damages only.
The remand tells the Central District of California to reinstate the jury’s liability verdict and try the dollar amount again. Gutierrez, who retired after the trial, had ruled that without economists Daniel Rascher and Dr. Zona, no reasonable jury could find class-wide injury. The panel said that step went past a judge’s job as a gatekeeper under Rule 702.
Opinions are neither unfounded nor unreliable merely because they are impeachable. Such opinions are for the jury to weigh at trial. Once a jury does so, its verdict must stand unless it is clearly not supported by the evidence.
Judge Anthony D. Johnstone, Ninth Circuit opinion, October 30, 2026
The first public reading of the decision treated the $4.7 billion as restored. The opinion does not do that. It puts the legal finding back on the docket and sends the number to a new jury. Paul Clement argued the appeal for the NFL in San Francisco on March 9, 2026. Amanda K. Bonn of Susman Godfrey argued for the subscribers.
Named plaintiffs include Ninth Inning Inc., which does business as The Mucky Duck in San Francisco, Gael Pub, Robert Gary Lippincott Jr., and Jonathan Frantz. The suit, filed in 2015, covers DirecTV buyers in the class period from June 2011 through February 2023. Trial filings put that group at 2.4 million homes and 48,000 businesses across the 2011 through 2022 seasons.
How the Jury Turned a Discount Into $4.7 Billion
Jurors were told to measure the gap between what buyers paid for Sunday Ticket and what they would have paid if the clubs had not pooled those rights. They did not follow that path. They took a 2018-19 list price of $294.00, subtracted an average paid price of $102.74, and treated the $191.26 gap as an overcharge, which the trial judge later called a discount.
THE JURY’S DAMAGE MATH
| Input | Figure |
|---|---|
| Residential records | 24,105,049 |
| Commercial records | 506,788 |
| List price used | $294.00 |
| Average price paid | $102.74 |
| Gap treated as an overcharge | $191.26 |
| Residential award | $4,610,331,671.74 |
| Commercial award | $96,928,272.90 |
| Combined award | $4,707,259,944.64 |
| If trebled under 15 U.S.C. § 15 | $14,121,779,833.92 |
The Ninth Circuit recited those residential and commercial counts as the class figures the jury multiplied by $191.26. That is a different tally from the 2.4 million unique homes in the trial filings, because a person who bought the package in several seasons is counted more than once. Gutierrez found the method was not based on the evidence and reasonable inferences. The panel said he was within his discretion to infer how the jury got there and to order a do-over on damages.
A new award, if it becomes a judgment, is still subject to automatic trebling. Clayton Act § 4 says a private plaintiff “shall recover threefold the damages by him sustained,” plus costs and a reasonable attorney’s fee. The 2024 combined figure of $4.7 billion, if it had been trebled, would have been $14.12 billion. Plaintiffs had asked for as much as $7.01 billion before the first trial. None of those sums is the number a second jury must write.
College Football Was the Yardstick the Judge Rejected
Rascher, an economist and professor at the University of San Francisco, told the jury that college football after the NCAA lost control of Saturday telecasts was a fair comparison. He said more NFL games would have shown up on basic TV, or at a lower add-on price, if clubs could sell out-of-market rights on their own. Gutierrez later called that model speculation and ipse dixit, a bare assertion dressed as expertise.
Johnstone had already flagged the comparison at argument. “If that’s not a yardstick, what is?” he asked. The opinion answered in the same vein: yardsticks use a real market to sketch a world without the challenged deals, and Rascher’s method was reliable enough to reach a jury. Weaknesses, the panel said, were for cross-examination, not a late strike after the verdict.
Zona, the damages economist, modeled extra distributors. He estimated that one added rival would cut the DirecTV Sunday Ticket price by 49.7 percent, and that exclusivity cost residential class members $2.81 billion and commercial members $670 million. Those Zona totals are a separate model, not the $4.7 billion the jury returned. Gutierrez also rejected an “NFL Tax” theory that the league and the Sunday networks priced the extra package high so it would not pull viewers from CBS and Fox.
John Mark Newman, a University of Memphis law professor and former deputy director of the FTC’s Bureau of Competition, called the post-trial strike retroactively excluding expert testimony the judge had already allowed “a travesty of justice.” Sports Fans Coalition, which filed as a friend of the court, said tossing the liability finding after the jury had spoken was like a referee flagging a game-winning score when nobody saw a foul. The panel agreed on the experts and still refused to bless the $4.7 billion.
The 1961 Act Never Covered a Paid Bundle
Sunday Ticket exists in a legal gap Congress cut in 1961 and never widened. After a Philadelphia court blocked the clubs from selling a pooled CBS package, Congress passed the Sports Broadcasting Act. The statute, now 15 U.S.C. § 1291, gives leagues an exemption for sponsored telecasting of games, the free, ad-supported broadcasts that still carry home-market Sunday games on CBS and Fox.
THE 1961 EXEMPTION
- The trigger: A 1961 district court held that pooling club TV rights eliminated competition among teams in selling those rights.
- The statute: Congress answered with an antitrust pass for joint sales of sponsored telecasting, signed on September 30, 1961.
- The limit: Courts have read “sponsored telecasting” as free over-the-air TV, not a paid satellite or streaming bundle.
- The product at issue: Sunday Ticket is sold as an extra subscription, so it sits outside that pass.
The 1961 order that blocked pooled TV rights is why the league went to Congress in the first place. Pete Rozelle wanted one national package and equal shares for every club. That model still funds the free Sunday window. The paid out-of-market stack is a later product, launched with DirecTV in 1994, and it is the product the 2024 jury said crossed the Sherman Act.
The NFL’s answer is distribution, not the 1961 text. It says 100 percent of games are on free TV in the markets of the teams that are playing, and that 87 percent of games are on free broadcast television, a contrast with NBA, MLB, and NHL local blackouts on paid regional nets. The panel did not retry that policy case. It held that the subscribers’ experts should have been left with the jury, and that the first jury’s price math still cannot stand.
Thirty-Two Clubs Share One Unwritten Check
Every club is a defendant. The caption runs from the Cardinals through Washington Football, plus NFL Enterprises and the DirecTV entities. If a future award were trebled at the 2024 scale, the bill would come to about $441 million per club before interest. That is a cash call, not a salary-cap entry, and it is still hypothetical because the $4.7 billion is off the board.
THE MONEY STILL IN PLAY
- Combined 2024 award: $4,707,259,944.64, commonly rounded to $4.7 billion, which the panel would not restore.
- Automatic treble: $14,121,779,833.92 if that combined figure had become a judgment under 15 U.S.C. § 15.
- Per club at that scale: about $441 million, split 32 ways, before statutory interest.
- League take in the class years: more than $100 billion, with 46 of the 50 most-watched U.S. TV programs in 2021 being NFL games.
Owners are the hidden balance sheet. A Super Bowl-size check is not the same event as a finding that the clubs, acting together, broke Sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Act. The finding is what a second jury will be told is already decided. The check is what that jury, or a settlement, still has to invent from admissible proof.
A large headline number also gets sliced. The jury’s own multiplier used more than 24 million residential records. Even a nine-figure commercial award, spread across hundreds of thousands of bar and restaurant bills, is not a windfall a neighborhood pub can spend. The Mucky Duck has been in the caption for 11 years. Its stake is the liability finding and whatever per-subscriber figure survives a retrial, after fees.
YouTube Now Sells the Same Out-of-Market Package
DirecTV carried Sunday Ticket from 1994 through the 2022 season. YouTube took the package in 2023 under a seven-year pact with the NFL. Returning subscribers pay about $480 for the current season on YouTube’s stand-alone path. The suit’s class years stop in February 2023, so the Google contract is not the contract the 2024 jury priced.
The product shape has not changed. Out-of-market Sunday afternoon games on CBS and Fox still sit behind one bundled extra. Home games stay on free local TV. Thursday, Sunday night, and Monday packages stay with other rights holders. Fans who want only one club, or one division, still buy the whole stack or go without.
We continue to believe that our media distribution strategy, which features 100 percent of NFL games broadcast on free over-the-air television in the markets of the participating teams and national distribution of our most popular games, supplemented by many additional choices including RedZone, Sunday Ticket, and NFL Plus, is by far the most fan-friendly distribution model in all of sports and entertainment.
NFL spokesperson, statement, October 30, 2026
The panel also sent the request for a court order, the injunction class, back to Los Angeles. It agreed the end of the DirecTV deal means the trial court must ask whether those claims are now moot. A restored liability verdict on the old exclusive pact does not, by itself, make the YouTube deal unlawful. It does leave a judicial finding that this kind of pooled, paid out-of-market bundle crossed the Sherman Act, sitting next to a live product that still looks like that bundle.
The League Will Ask the Full Ninth Circuit to Step In
The NFL said on October 30 it was disappointed and was weighing further review. On November 6, sports business reporter Daniel Kaplan wrote that the league plans an en banc petition, a request that the full Ninth Circuit rehear the panel. Either side can also ask the Supreme Court to take the case, though a damages retrial may have to finish before the dispute is ripe there.
THE SUNDAY TICKET CASE FILE
- July 20, 1961: A Philadelphia court blocks the NFL from pooling club television rights for a single CBS deal.
- September 30, 1961: Congress passes the Sports Broadcasting Act for sponsored telecasting.
- 1994: Sunday Ticket launches as a paid DirecTV package of out-of-market Sunday games.
- 2015: Subscribers file the class action in federal court in California.
- June 27, 2024: A Los Angeles jury finds liability and returns the $4.7 billion award.
- August 1, 2024: Judge Gutierrez enters judgment for the NFL and, in the alternative, orders a new damages trial.
- March 9, 2026: The Ninth Circuit hears argument in San Francisco.
- October 30, 2026: The panel restores liability and keeps the damages do-over.
- November 6, 2026: The league’s plan for an en banc appeal is reported.
Judge George H. Wu now has the Central District file. He has to set a damages trial unless a larger appellate court stays that work. A second jury would hear the case with the liability verdict already in place, and with Rascher and Zona allowed in, which is a different trial from the one Gutierrez tried to end in 2024.
The $4.7 billion is not a judgment. The finding that Sunday Ticket’s pooled rights deal broke antitrust law is back on the books, and that is the part the clubs have to live with while they fight the next round.
Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of a federal appeals court decision. It is informational only and is not legal advice, a prediction of any future award, or a recommendation to join, opt out of, or settle any claim. Readers with a stake in the Sunday Ticket litigation should consult a licensed attorney who can review their own facts and the current docket. Figures, party positions, and case status are drawn from the October 30, 2026, opinion and related public statements and may change with an en banc petition, a new trial, or a later settlement.
-
BUSINESS3 months agoConsumer Sentiment Falls to 51.7 as Future Outlook Darkens
-
GAMING3 months agoTake-Two Subpoenas Microsoft While GTA 6 Preorders Soar
-
NEWS3 months agoPluto’s Heart Glacier Still Pushes Liquid Nitrogen Upward
-
NEWS3 months agoThe Extra Heat Month Hits Children Where Care Is Thinnest
-
ENTERTAINMENT3 months agoNetflix Weighs Hosting Peacock and Fox One in Its App
-
NEWS3 months agoFDA Clears Rasonque and Widens Who Can Take It
-
NEWS3 months agoUMMC Will Rebuild 30-Year-Old Cancer Labs With $2.4 Million
-
GAMING3 months agoGTA 6’s 80-Hour Run Counts Goals That Change the Story
